Ron is Dumbledore (interesting)

[GaToRaDeIsGo0d4234]

im confused, but what i think is that its not likely that ron and dumbledore r the same. time travel is confusing either it already happened or it happend but u think u didnt do it

[GaToRaDeIsGo0d4234]

that made no sense

[~*Padfoot*~]

it made sense to me...in a slighty confused way, lol, but i'm sticking to my beliefs

here is a well thought out picture of the ron=dd path, if you're still with me up to this point, please explain how this wouldn't work if you want but please don't say it won't work without any backup to your answer

[pantstheterrible]

That would work, but Ron wouldn't be able to change anything. If he changed it he may not travel later in the future and it wouldn't happen. Meh! It's hard to explain! What a paradox! Circles circles circles!

[pantstheterrible]

Footy said

if you go back and change something (as long as your past self doesn't recognize you or touch you) you can change history, think about "Back to the Future", history changed in that, i don't see why if you go back in time and do something, that the future will change (ex. again sorry for using but i'm firm to it, buckbeak) if you say it already happened, then what's the use of harry and hermione even going back in the first place if

Yes, but that's Back to the future, not Harry Potter. With the way she worked it in PoA they can't change anything. For what's the use of going back if it already happened, if they didn't go back it wouldn't happen. Duh.

[~*Padfoot*~]

hehe, i know what you mean, time travel is confusing, *goes crazy*

[GaToRaDeIsGo0d4234]

that makes some sense, but ron isnt that good w/ spells and i think he couldnt do that well of accomplishments unless dumbledore says to ron go back in time and become him then itd make sense, but i doubt it, it does make sense

[pantstheterrible]

Hey yeah, Dumbledore(Ron) could tell Ron to go back. That would make sense. That makes it more believable.

[~*Padfoot*~]

someone on the forum site link that i posted talked about this, i'm too busy to check right now, but i'll read up on it (wow, i sound like hermy) but i know there was a answer to this question that supported the ron=dd as well , lol

[GaToRaDeIsGo0d4234]

i feel so dumb right , im the most confused ive been in my life, lol

[~*Padfoot*~]

don't worry, i'm sure we're all a lttle confused but enlightened too (hopefully?) *gives a cookie* ;D

[GaToRaDeIsGo0d4234]

but do u think jk rowling would do that

[pantstheterrible]

Oh, she could.

[GaToRaDeIsGo0d4234]

its her style but not her style, its her style by making something farfeth=ched like that happen and because its just to weird

[pantstheterrible]

Maybe this will help you understand me Footy. I found this from a link off of your link. Click on Time Travel Explained. It's off to the right. Then click on #3 under changes. Read it and maybe you will understand me.