Post by Black on Jun 27, 2004 20:45:24 GMT -5
How could JKR kill off Sirius??
It's as if Harry is getting one big dissapointment after another! Sirius has 2 come back or harry will be soooo sad!
according to Luna Lovegood’s dad’s tabloid, someone who looked exactly like Sirius (under the name Stubby Boardman, I believe) was eating dinner with a girl a year later, the night Wormtail committed all the murders.
He told the girl he had left public life a year earlier. I think that was the brother, and he was in hiding so Voldemort’s followers wouldn’t find and kill him. 15 years later, Harry comes to save Sirius at the Ministry of Magic, but in the death scene, none of the adults ever call Sirius by name, and Bellatrix only refers to him as “cousin” or the “Animagus Black”- so it could be Regulus. Being an animagus would help him hide for 15 years, too. And if you read the death scene carefully, Harry never gets a good look at Sirius; his face is bloody, and Harry has “watery eyes.” Dumbledore is the only one who actually says that Sirius is dead. Maybe he wants Harry to believe it so he won’t endanger himself further. Also, if Sirius was upstairs helping Buckbeak when Harry talked to Kreacher through the fire, and the rest of the house was empty, how did Sirius catch up with the others to enter the room with the veil at the exact same time? Maybe Regulus was the one with them all along. Perhaps he joined the Order because he knew the Death Eaters won’t have him back. It’s very plausible that he stumbled upon the Order when he came back home to Grimmauld Place. One last thing- Luna Lovegood at the end is looking for her stolen possessions, while Harry is moping about Sirius. Luna says several times for Harry not to worry- she always finds what she lost- it always comes back to her, etc. Is this a little foreshadowing that Sirius will come back? I hope so!!! - Submitted by the Jackson Clan
There was something in JK Rowling about book 6 which she has already started writing. Umm Siruis', god rest his soul, motorbike will return to Harry and also you'll find where Lily and James graves are. Those are two facts. I don't know where people got that the next books title is the green flame torch cause JK says she hasnt given the book a name yet. - Submitted by Maria
Ok, I can be very wrong, but hear me out. I found it very interesting when Sirius fell through the veil; 'What's on the other side i asked?' The voices and the way they drew you in. Obviously Sirius knew what it was because of the look of fear he gave as he fell in. Luna Lovegood is the one that brought me to this idea, that it's a passage to the land of the dead. In chapter 38 of OP she says that she could hear "them" behind the veil.
Referring to her dead mother and others who have passed on. Now Sirius could very well be alive in the land of the dead. Nothing says that he can't walk amongst in that land, nothing yet anyway. Aside from that this veil could be Harry's way to communicate to Sirius and his Parents dead, alive, or otherwise. I doubt this will come up in book 6 because it completely destroys the meaning and effect of the Sirius' death in my opinion, perhaps book 7. In anycase the fact that Sirius fell through the veil stunned, not dead, leads me to believe he COULD be alive but in the land of the dead.
It's as if Harry is getting one big dissapointment after another! Sirius has 2 come back or harry will be soooo sad!
according to Luna Lovegood’s dad’s tabloid, someone who looked exactly like Sirius (under the name Stubby Boardman, I believe) was eating dinner with a girl a year later, the night Wormtail committed all the murders.
He told the girl he had left public life a year earlier. I think that was the brother, and he was in hiding so Voldemort’s followers wouldn’t find and kill him. 15 years later, Harry comes to save Sirius at the Ministry of Magic, but in the death scene, none of the adults ever call Sirius by name, and Bellatrix only refers to him as “cousin” or the “Animagus Black”- so it could be Regulus. Being an animagus would help him hide for 15 years, too. And if you read the death scene carefully, Harry never gets a good look at Sirius; his face is bloody, and Harry has “watery eyes.” Dumbledore is the only one who actually says that Sirius is dead. Maybe he wants Harry to believe it so he won’t endanger himself further. Also, if Sirius was upstairs helping Buckbeak when Harry talked to Kreacher through the fire, and the rest of the house was empty, how did Sirius catch up with the others to enter the room with the veil at the exact same time? Maybe Regulus was the one with them all along. Perhaps he joined the Order because he knew the Death Eaters won’t have him back. It’s very plausible that he stumbled upon the Order when he came back home to Grimmauld Place. One last thing- Luna Lovegood at the end is looking for her stolen possessions, while Harry is moping about Sirius. Luna says several times for Harry not to worry- she always finds what she lost- it always comes back to her, etc. Is this a little foreshadowing that Sirius will come back? I hope so!!! - Submitted by the Jackson Clan
There was something in JK Rowling about book 6 which she has already started writing. Umm Siruis', god rest his soul, motorbike will return to Harry and also you'll find where Lily and James graves are. Those are two facts. I don't know where people got that the next books title is the green flame torch cause JK says she hasnt given the book a name yet. - Submitted by Maria
Ok, I can be very wrong, but hear me out. I found it very interesting when Sirius fell through the veil; 'What's on the other side i asked?' The voices and the way they drew you in. Obviously Sirius knew what it was because of the look of fear he gave as he fell in. Luna Lovegood is the one that brought me to this idea, that it's a passage to the land of the dead. In chapter 38 of OP she says that she could hear "them" behind the veil.
Referring to her dead mother and others who have passed on. Now Sirius could very well be alive in the land of the dead. Nothing says that he can't walk amongst in that land, nothing yet anyway. Aside from that this veil could be Harry's way to communicate to Sirius and his Parents dead, alive, or otherwise. I doubt this will come up in book 6 because it completely destroys the meaning and effect of the Sirius' death in my opinion, perhaps book 7. In anycase the fact that Sirius fell through the veil stunned, not dead, leads me to believe he COULD be alive but in the land of the dead.
[/glow]